Building Management | Facility Management | Risk Management | Building Operations
When Everyone Wants to Be First
Life in building and facility management can become overwhelming, particularly when several significant issues arise at the same time.
There are days when the building runs relatively smoothly. Contractors arrive when expected, tenants are reasonably satisfied, maintenance activities proceed to schedule, and expenditure remains within budget.
Then there are the other days.
A major mechanical failure, a disgruntled tenant, an urgent compliance issue, an unhappy landlord, an unexpected contractor variation and an approaching financial deadline can all arrive within hours of one another.
Suddenly, everybody wants an answer. More importantly, everybody believes their problem should take priority.
And somewhere in the middle is the Building Manager or Facility Manager, trying to balance operational requirements, safety obligations, commercial relationships and financial responsibilities.
One of the first things to come under pressure is loyalty.
Who do you look after first?
- The tenant making the most noise?
- The tenant paying the highest rent?
- The organisation representing the greatest potential for future business?
- The landlord who ultimately pays your wages or invoices?
- The tenant with whom the landlord has a particularly good relationship?
- The organisation threatening legal action?
- The issue most likely to affect your reputation or job security?
- Or perhaps the problem that can be resolved quickly, allowing at least one item to be removed from an increasingly long list?
Too many competing interests. Too many expectations. Too many decisions.
And not nearly enough time.
The challenge is that building management is not simply about keeping equipment operational or contractors organised. It requires judgement, independence and the ability to make defensible decisions when circumstances are less than ideal.
So, Who Actually Comes First?
Safety comes first. Always.
Not rental income, reputation, investment value, professional relationships, tenant influence or even the immediate cost of resolving an issue.
The protection of people and the management of immediate hazards must take precedence.
In a commercial building, this includes maintaining safe access and egress, protecting occupants from electrical and mechanical hazards, and preserving the integrity of fire and life-safety systems.
However, there is an important distinction.
An emergency does not provide unlimited authority to spend money, bypass every established procedure or accept the first contractor’s recommendation without question.
Urgency may justify immediate action to make an area safe, isolate damaged equipment or prevent further loss. It does not necessarily justify committing to an expensive permanent solution without adequate consideration.
Where time permits, appropriate processes should still be followed.
That might involve obtaining alternative quotations, consulting specialist engineers, checking contractual obligations, confirming insurance requirements or seeking approval from the asset owner.
The difficult part is knowing which decisions cannot wait and which decisions should wait.
Let’s consider an example.
A Sunday Morning in a 25-Storey Commercial Office Building
Picture a 25-level commercial office building in a major Australian CBD.
It is Sunday morning. The building is largely unoccupied, apart from security personnel, cleaners and perhaps a handful of tenants working over the weekend.
Somewhere around the middle levels, a 250 mm chilled-water pipe fails at a joint.
Not a minor leak. A substantial failure.
Thousands of litres of chilled water begin discharging into the building.
Water spreads across the floor, enters service risers, travels down through penetrations and eventually finds its way into several lower levels.
One lift shaft is affected. Water begins collecting in lift pits, electrical cupboards and common-area lobbies.
Carpets are saturated. Ceiling tiles collapse. Water runs down walls and through light fittings.
The fire detection system has not activated because the incident has not necessarily produced a condition that would initiate a fire alarm.
However, water detection sensors beneath the raised floor in a tenant’s computer room have operated.
An alarm is received by the monitoring provider. Someone attends to investigate. The extent of the problem becomes apparent.
Then the Facility Manager receives the call.
And the process begins.
The Situation on Arrival
By the time the Facility Manager arrives, the initial torrent has reduced.
Much of the chilled-water system has already emptied through the failed joint.
Unfortunately, the automatic make-up water system remains active, continuing to introduce water into the damaged system.
What was initially a major discharge has become a continuous, smaller flow.
The lower levels have suffered considerable water damage.
The building’s basement drainage and sump pumps have managed to remove some of the water reaching the lower levels. Fortunately, those systems remain operational, although they were never intended to manage a major chilled-water pipe failure.
The full extent of the damage is not yet known.
There is no air-conditioning available, because the failed chilled-water pipe is part of the building’s main cooling distribution system.
Several tenants are affected differently. Some occupy entire floors and have suffered extensive water damage. Others have relatively minor damage near the lift lobby or common areas.
One tenant has a critical computer room.
Another has expensive floor finishes.
Another has equipment that cannot tolerate prolonged exposure to high temperatures.
Meanwhile, the building owner wants to know how much the incident will cost.
The managing agent wants to know when the building will reopen.
And the tenants want to know whether they can operate on Monday morning.
It’s Sunday. The clock is ticking.
The Domino Effect – One Failure, Multiple Building Systems
A failed chilled-water pipe is rarely just a mechanical services problem.
The water may have originated from an HVAC system, but its consequences can spread throughout the building.
Electrical Systems
Water may have entered electrical distribution boards, lighting circuits, control panels, switchboard rooms and cable pathways.
Some equipment may require immediate isolation by appropriately qualified personnel.
Other equipment may appear unaffected but still require inspection, testing or specialist assessment before being safely re-energised.
Equipment that is dry on the outside is not necessarily safe on the inside.
Lift Systems
Water entering a lift shaft can affect lift pits, electrical equipment, travelling cables, controllers and associated safety devices.
The lift contractor may need to remove affected lifts from service until inspections and necessary repairs are complete.
Suddenly, the building may have reduced vertical transport capacity or no operational lifts in part of the building.
What happens if the building is expected to accommodate thousands of people on Monday morning?
Fire and Life-Safety Systems
Water may affect fire detection equipment, emergency lighting, evacuation systems, smoke control interfaces, fire-rated penetrations or other essential safety measures.
These systems must be assessed according to their actual exposure and condition.
A conventional HVAC failure is now potentially a building compliance and occupancy issue.
The Facility Manager must understand whether essential safety measures remain operational and what restrictions or interim arrangements may be necessary.
Security and Access Control
Card readers, electronic door locks, access-control panels, communications equipment and security systems may also have been exposed.
Failure of an access-control system might inconvenience tenants.
Failure of a door release arrangement associated with emergency egress may have far more serious consequences.
The distinction matters.
Building Automation and Mechanical Services
The Building Management System may have correctly identified abnormal chilled-water pressures, pump operation or other conditions.
Alternatively, it may have failed to provide a meaningful warning.
The Facility Manager needs to establish whether the system was designed to detect this type of failure, whether appropriate alarms were configured and whether the sequence of operation contributed to the continuing discharge.
Could the make-up water have been automatically isolated?
Were abnormal pressure or water-consumption conditions monitored?
Were alarms generated but not acted upon?
These questions may become important later, but they should not distract from the immediate response.
Building Fabric and Tenant Fitouts
The physical damage can be extensive.
Carpets, plasterboard, joinery, doors, ceilings, insulation, furniture and specialist floor coverings may all be affected.
Some materials can be recovered through prompt drying and restoration.
Others will require replacement.
And beneath the visible damage may be concealed moisture that creates further problems weeks or months later.
The longer the water remains, the more complicated the recovery may become.
The Phone Starts Ringing – And the Competing Loyalties Return
Within a short period, the Facility Manager may receive calls from:
- The asset owner, demanding an explanation and an estimated cost.
- The property manager, wanting to understand the effect on tenants and lease obligations.
- The mechanical contractor, recommending urgent replacement of damaged pipework.
- The electrical contractor, identifying equipment that must remain isolated.
- The lift contractor, advising that affected lifts cannot operate.
- The fire services contractor, raising concerns about damaged safety equipment.
- Tenant representatives, demanding certainty about access and business continuity.
- The insurer or insurance broker, requesting information and evidence.
Each has a legitimate interest.
But their priorities are not necessarily the same.
The landlord may be concerned about financial exposure and reputation.
The tenants may be concerned about business interruption.
Contractors may be focused on restoring their particular systems.
The insurer will want appropriate documentation, mitigation and compliance with policy conditions.
The Property Manager may be concerned about lease commitments and tenant relationships.
And the Facility Manager must somehow coordinate all of them.
This is where the ability to distinguish between urgency, importance and influence becomes critical.
The loudest stakeholder is not automatically the highest priority.
Nor is the highest-paying tenant.
Nor is the contractor with the most expensive recommendation.
The First Decisions – Stabilise Before You Rebuild
The initial objective should not be to restore the entire building immediately.
It should be to stabilise the situation.
That means establishing a safe and controlled environment where the damage is no longer escalating.
Depending on site conditions and the assessment of qualified personnel, immediate actions may include:
- Isolating the damaged chilled-water system and stopping the automatic make-up supply.
- Identifying and controlling electrical hazards, including isolation of affected equipment where required.
- Restricting access to unsafe areas and confirming safe evacuation routes.
- Assessing whether fire and life-safety systems remain operational.
- Securing affected lifts and arranging specialist inspections.
- Engaging appropriate water extraction and restoration contractors.
- Establishing the extent of damage and documenting conditions before substantial removal or disposal of materials.
These activities may occur concurrently rather than sequentially.
The crucial consideration is that each action should contribute to protecting people, preventing further damage or establishing a safe basis for recovery.
There may be little value in replacing damaged carpet while water is still entering the building.
Likewise, there may be little value in urgently repairing the chilled-water pipe if electrical systems, lifts and essential safety measures cannot be safely returned to service.
Restoring one building service does not necessarily restore the building.
The First Contractor Arrives with a Solution
Let’s assume the mechanical contractor has inspected the failed pipework.
They recommend an emergency repair involving removal of the failed section, new fittings, specialist labour and significant after-hours expenditure.
They can mobilise immediately.
They also provide a substantial quotation.
The landlord wants the air-conditioning restored.
The tenants want to return to work.
The contractor warns that any delay will push completion beyond Monday.
It would be easy to approve the proposal simply to demonstrate that something is being done.
But what does the Facility Manager actually know?
Has the extent of damage been established?
Was the joint failure an isolated event, or is there evidence of a wider problem with the pipework?
Does the proposed repair represent a temporary measure or a permanent solution?
Is the quoted scope appropriate?
Could another contractor provide a technically equivalent solution?
Will the repaired system need pressure testing, flushing, water treatment or recommissioning before returning to operation?
And who has the authority to approve the expenditure?
These questions do not disappear because it is Sunday.
Sometimes there is no practical opportunity to obtain competitive quotations before undertaking essential emergency work.
In other circumstances, temporary isolation may provide sufficient time to consider alternative solutions.
The skill lies in recognising the difference.
Where emergency expenditure is unavoidable, it should be limited to what is reasonably necessary, properly authorised wherever practicable, and recorded with a clear explanation of the circumstances.
A contractor’s urgency is not necessarily the building’s urgency.
Monday Morning – Who Gets Their Floor Back First?
Now consider the next stage.
The immediate water discharge has been stopped.
The building is being dried.
Some electrical services have been assessed and restored.
Other systems remain unavailable.
The chilled-water repair is underway, but air-conditioning will not be restored throughout the building in time for normal Monday occupancy.
Several floors remain inaccessible.
The landlord has three major tenants:
Tenant A occupies five floors and pays substantial rent. Their offices have relatively minor water damage, but air-conditioning is unavailable.
Tenant B occupies one floor and has suffered significant damage to electrical and communications equipment.
Tenant C occupies two floors. They have an important relationship with the landlord and are demanding priority access, despite comparatively limited damage.
Who comes first?
The answer cannot be determined by rental income alone.
The initial question should be whether any part of the building can be safely occupied.
Once that has been established, decisions about partial occupancy, restoration priority and temporary arrangements should consider the nature of the hazards, actual service availability, operational dependencies, business continuity requirements and agreed contractual obligations.
Where safe and practical, some tenants may be able to return before others.
Where critical systems are unavailable, certain areas may remain closed regardless of commercial pressure.
And where the situation warrants it, specialist engineers, building surveyors, relevant authorities or other competent professionals may need to be involved before occupancy resumes.
This is not about giving every tenant exactly the same outcome.
It is about applying consistent, transparent and defensible criteria.
Fairness does not always mean equal treatment.
It means decisions are justified by the circumstances rather than by the influence of the people asking.
The Financial Pressure – When Emergency Spending Gets Away
Major incidents create another problem that can quickly become overwhelming.
Expenditure.
A mechanical contractor is repairing the pipe.
An electrical contractor is assessing switchboards.
A lift contractor is inspecting damaged equipment.
A restoration company has installed drying equipment.
A fire contractor is checking essential safety systems.
A builder has commenced opening walls and ceilings.
Before long, several contractors may be working simultaneously, each operating under different call-out rates, labour arrangements, scopes and assumptions.
Some are working on a time-and-materials basis.
Others have submitted quotations.
Some may be undertaking essential emergency works.
Others may have moved into reinstatement activities without a clearly defined approval.
This is where costs can escalate rapidly.
The Facility Manager needs a way to distinguish between:
Emergency stabilisation: Work necessary to remove immediate hazards and prevent additional damage.
Investigation and assessment: Work required to determine the extent of damage and identify appropriate recovery options.
Temporary restoration: Measures that allow part of the building to operate safely while permanent solutions are developed.
Permanent reinstatement: Repairs and replacements required to return the building to its intended operating condition.
Betterment or capital improvements: Work that goes beyond reinstating the pre-incident condition and may require separate owner approval or funding.
These are different activities with different commercial implications.
They should not automatically be treated as one uncontrolled emergency project.
The Facility Manager should also ensure that the insurer or broker is notified promptly, relevant policy requirements are understood, expenditure is recorded and appropriate evidence is retained.
Waiting until the final invoices arrive is too late to begin cost control.
Communication – Everybody Needs Information, But Not Everybody Needs the Same Information
One of the greatest sources of frustration during a major building incident is poor communication.
When reliable information is unavailable, speculation fills the gap.
Tenants begin contacting the landlord directly.
The landlord contacts the Property Manager.
The Property Manager contacts the Facility Manager.
Contractors provide conflicting estimates.
Everyone wants another update.
The Facility Manager can end up spending more time answering the telephone than coordinating the recovery.
A structured communication process can reduce this pressure.
The asset owner and managing agent need reliable information concerning safety, financial exposure, building availability, restoration strategy and significant decisions requiring approval.
Tenants need practical information concerning access, affected services, safety restrictions and likely operational impacts.
Contractors need clear instructions, defined work areas, agreed priorities and an understanding of which activities have been authorised.
The insurer needs timely notification, appropriate evidence and information relevant to the claim.
Not every stakeholder requires the same level of technical detail.
And where the extent of damage or recovery time remains uncertain, the communication should say so.
A realistic statement of uncertainty is more valuable than a confident completion date that cannot be supported.
The Building Is Operational Again. Is the Job Finished?
Eventually, the water is removed.
The chilled-water system is repaired.
The lifts return to service.
Electrical installations are assessed and restored.
Carpets and ceilings are replaced.
The tenants return.
The contractors submit their final invoices.
Everybody moves on.
Or do they?
A major incident should also prompt an investigation into why the failure occurred and whether the consequences could have been reduced.
Consider the original chilled-water pipe failure.
Was the joint installed correctly?
Was there excessive mechanical stress, vibration, corrosion or movement?
Had maintenance or inspections identified early warning signs?
Why did the make-up water continue operating?
Could an abnormal pressure or make-up water consumption alarm have provided earlier warning?
Were water detection systems installed in the most vulnerable locations?
Did the Building Management System have sufficient monitoring and alarm escalation arrangements?
Did the building’s emergency response procedures identify the appropriate isolation valves?
Could contractors access the building and locate essential equipment without delay?
Were drawings and asset registers current?
Was the landlord’s emergency expenditure approval process suitable for a Sunday morning incident?
These are not simply technical questions.
They relate to asset management, risk, operational preparedness and long-term building performance.
A successful recovery should include a documented review of the incident, its underlying causes, the response and the opportunities for improvement.
Otherwise, the building may return to operation with many of the same vulnerabilities that allowed the original incident to become so costly.
The Overlooked Risk – The Building Manager
There is another aspect of these situations that is rarely discussed.
The effect on the person managing the incident.
A major building failure can require continuous coordination over several days.
Normal responsibilities do not disappear.
Scheduled maintenance still needs attention.
Other buildings may still require management.
Tenants continue raising unrelated issues.
Invoices need processing. Meetings remain scheduled. Compliance obligations do not stop.
Meanwhile, the Facility Manager is expected to make technical, operational and commercial decisions while working extended hours and under considerable pressure.
Fatigue can affect judgement.
A poorly considered instruction can create unnecessary expenditure.
A missed detail can delay recovery.
An undocumented decision can become difficult to defend months later.
And when an incident is eventually reviewed, the decisions made by the Facility Manager may receive considerable scrutiny.
This is why significant incidents should not rely entirely on the capacity of one individual.
Appropriate delegation, additional technical support, clearly defined decision-making authority and structured reporting can materially improve the response.
Experienced Building Managers understand their buildings.
But they should not be expected to personally possess every specialist skill required to manage a major mechanical, electrical, fire, structural or insurance-related incident.
Knowing when to bring in independent expertise is part of competent management.
Where Does Professional Loyalty Actually Sit?
We return to the original question.
When everybody is demanding attention, who should the Building Manager look after first?
The answer is not always simple.
There are contractual obligations to employers, clients and property owners.
There are commercial relationships to maintain.
There are tenants with legitimate operational requirements.
There are contractors who need instructions and payments.
And there are budgets that cannot be ignored.
But professional loyalty should not be confused with personal preference, commercial influence or the desire to keep the loudest stakeholder satisfied.
The Building Manager’s responsibility is to exercise sound judgement within their authority, meet legal and contractual obligations, protect people, manage risk and act in the interests of the property without compromising professional integrity.
Sometimes that means telling an important tenant they cannot reoccupy their premises.
Sometimes it means telling the landlord that an expensive repair cannot be avoided.
Sometimes it means challenging a contractor’s recommendation.
And sometimes it means advising everyone that the correct decision is to delay restoration until the necessary assessments have been completed.
Those are not always popular decisions.
But they may be the right ones.
Good Building Management Is Most Visible When Things Go Wrong
The performance of a Building Manager is often judged by the number of complaints received, the appearance of the property or whether maintenance expenditure remains within budget.
Those measures have their place.
However, they do not always reflect the complexity of managing a commercial building.
When a significant incident occurs, the real value of competent building and facility management becomes much more apparent.
It is demonstrated through the ability to understand interconnected building systems, establish priorities, coordinate specialists, manage expenditure, communicate effectively and make decisions that remain defensible long after the incident has passed.
The objective is not simply to fix the broken pipe.
It is to manage the consequences of the failure across the entire building, protect the interests of those affected and restore normal operations safely and efficiently.
Because when everything becomes urgent, the most important skill is knowing what must come first — and having the professional independence to act on it.
How Performance Facility Management Can Assist
At Performance Facility Management, we understand that managing a building involves far more than arranging maintenance contractors and responding to tenant complaints.
Commercial buildings are complex, interconnected environments. A failure in one service can affect multiple systems, building occupants and commercial operations.
We provide independent building management and technical advisory support to property owners, managing agents and facility managers, including:
- Building operations and technical support.
- Independent investigation of mechanical, electrical and building services failures.
- Contractor coordination, scope development and technical review.
- Building condition assessments and operational risk reviews.
- Asset registers, maintenance planning and lifecycle advice.
- Building services recommissioning and performance assessments.
- Technical support during significant incidents and recovery projects.
Whether the challenge is an isolated equipment failure, deteriorating building performance or the management of multiple competing operational priorities, our role is to help clients make informed, technically sound and commercially responsible decisions.
Managing a complex building issue?
Contact Performance Facility Management to discuss independent technical and building management support for your commercial property.
Melbourne | Sydney | Canberra
